Top 10 Best Toilet Plungers in 2023

It appears to be an effective tool for clearing toilet clogs, thanks to its unique beehive-shaped head and T-shaped handle. The design of the head, with a thick upper part and a thin, flexible bottom part, seems to create an airtight seal and prevent splashing, which is quite convenient.

The T-shaped handle with a matte finish sounds comfortable to hold, but its large size and weight might make it a bit challenging to carry around. Nevertheless, the primary function of easily clearing blockages is the key feature of this plunger, making it a valuable tool for addressing toilet clogs.

For those who are concerned about sanitation, you mentioned that there is an option to purchase a plunger holder that supports this product, which is a practical addition.

The Clorox toilet plunger stands out thanks to its 15-and-a-half-inch ergonomic handle. It includes a caddy that conceals the rubber head, maintaining a sleek and clean bathroom appearance. During our testing, this product efficiently cleared a clog with just four plunges and minimal effort, delivering a stress-free experience. Its ability to create an airtight seal around the pipe means you don’t have to exert much force, reducing splashing and making it easier to clean the floor afterward.

The handle features a broad, triangular tip at the top, ensuring it doesn’t dig into your hand during use. However, it’s made of a slippery material, which slightly affects ease of handling.

In terms of sanitation, this product received high marks for its self-opening and -closing caddy, complete with a drip tray inside. Thanks to excellent ventilation, the plunger head dries efficiently and can be stored without causing any wetness on the floor. It’s incredibly user-friendly, as it automatically opens when you lift the plunger and closes when you place it back in the caddy.

NEIKO’s toilet plunger boasts a four-step level suction cup design and claims to create a seal around almost any toilet drain opening. Its handle is constructed from aluminum, giving it an easy-to-use and stylish modern appearance. During our testing, this plunger effectively cleared a toilet paper blockage in just five plunges.

It certainly lived up to its claim by forming a tight seal around the toilet drain. With each plunge, we could feel water being pushed out without the need for excessive force, resulting in minimal splashing, which is a notable advantage. The handle is well-sized for gripping and accommodates hands of all sizes comfortably. However, there is a downside as the hook on the tip caused discomfort and disrupted the plunging process. Additionally, the lack of a rubber grip made it prone to slipping, making it challenging to maintain a secure grip.

One drawback is that it doesn’t come with a caddy, which affects its sanitation score. Nonetheless, it earns points for its aluminum handle, which is resistant to rust, mold, and household bacteria. For those with sanitation concerns, it might be worth considering purchasing a separate caddy with an attached toilet brush. If you’re worried about whether this plunger will fit your toilet or prefer to store it by hanging it on a hook, we recommend this product as a suitable choice.

During our testing, the Yanxus plunger required 11 pumps to clear a blockage, which wasn’t the most efficient result. However, the hard rubber head does an excellent job of creating a powerful seal, reducing the need for excessive strength during use. This mitigates the stress of having to plunge 11 times.

The plunger features an ergonomically designed handle with a rounded tip, making it reasonably easy to use. We didn’t experience any discomfort from the handle digging into our hands. However, it’s worth noting that the plunger weighs one pound and two ounces, which can make it a bit heavy when cleaning or moving it around. In terms of design, we were impressed by the self-opening and -closing caddy, which automatically opens when the plunger is lifted and closes when it’s placed back in the caddy. Additionally, it includes a ventilation slot to enhance airflow within the drip tray integrated into the caddy.

The Good Grips toilet plunger by OXO is designed with the concept of universal design in mind. Its rubber head is intended to work effectively on all types of toilets, including low-flush models. In our testing, it did require 11 plunges to clear a blockage, which may not be the most efficient performance. However, the plunger’s handle features a rounded tip, making it easy and stress-free to use, and the shaft’s surface offers a comfortable grip.

On the downside, this product weighs one pound and 2.4 ounces, making it somewhat challenging to handle during use. It performed poorly in terms of splash resistance, leading to water overflow. It’s advisable to cover the floor with rags or newspaper when using this product. However, the handle’s length was sufficient to prevent dirty water from splashing onto our hands.

The plunger comes with a self-opening and -closing holder, which includes a drip tray with excellent ventilation, facilitating efficient water evaporation. Nevertheless, due to the extended effort required to clear blockages and the significant splashing it causes, it falls a bit short compared to top-ranked products.

The Rocky Mountain Goods plunger is a compact option with a handle length of just nine inches. It’s versatile and can be used not only for toilets but also for sinks, bathtubs, and shower drains. In our testing, it required 10 plunges to clear a clogged pipe. Thanks to its snug fit to the drain at the bottom of the toilet bowl, it generated a decent amount of power when pushing water. However, a notable drawback of this plunger, especially for toilet use, is its short handle, which can result in dirty water getting on your hands. As a result, this plunger is best suited for toilets with a shallow bottom.

Despite its ability to minimize splashing, the wooden handle tends to get soaked with dirty water, raising sanitation concerns. Additionally, the wooden handle can be challenging to grip and push due to its material. On the plus side, it’s exceptionally lightweight, weighing in at only five ounces, making it very easy to carry. If your primary use for a plunger is for sinks or showers, this option may be worth considering.

Luigi’s toilet plunger claims to clear pipes by using water rather than air, thanks to its unique bellows-like design that can reach deep into the drain. However, in our testing, we found that even after 15 pumps, we were unable to unclog the pipe effectively. Blasting water through it didn’t require much strength, but it did result in a noticeable amount of splashing.

On the positive side, the wide tip of the handle made it easy to use. However, it’s worth noting that the joint in the handle appeared to be weak and prone to bending.

The included caddy received a good score in our evaluation. However, it’s important to note that the caddy is deep and lacks a drip tray, so it’s essential to keep it clean to avoid any potential mess. Despite its innovative approach, Luigi’s toilet plunger may not be the most effective choice for clearing clogs based on our testing experience.

The MR.SIGA toilet plunger and brush combo features an all-black design that adds a touch of chicness to your bathroom while keeping your essential toilet items conveniently organized. However, in our testing, this product proved less effective in unclogging pipes, moving the blockage only two inches after 15 plunges. This lack of performance may be attributed to the small size of the cup and its inability to create a tight seal.

Another concern we had was the thin tip of the handle, which could dig into your hand and make it challenging to use comfortably. In terms of splashing, we observed a significant amount of water overflowing from the bowl due to the need for vigorous plunging. While it appears to have a sanitary design with the included caddy, it’s important to note that it lacks a drip tray, which could be a drawback. Despite its sleek appearance and organizational benefits, the MR.SIGA toilet plunger and brush combo may not be the most efficient choice for effectively clearing clogs based on our testing experience.

The DEFLECTAIR is an accordion-type plunger designed to push out a substantial amount of water. One of its advantages is that both the handle and head can be disassembled, making it easy to clean. However, in our testing, it only managed to move a toilet paper blockage three-quarters of an inch after 15 plunges.

The accordion-style head has a tendency to retain a significant amount of water, requiring considerable force to push, which results in a notable amount of water spilling from the bowl during use. From a sanitation perspective, it’s user-friendly for cleaning purposes because it’s made of plastic and can be disassembled. However, it’s worth mentioning that it doesn’t come with a caddy, so you’ll need to place it directly on the floor for storage. While the DEFLECTAIR offers some conveniences like easy disassembly, its performance in terms of clearing clogs may leave something to be desired based on our testing experience.